Cutting through the spin on supermassive black holes

How is the spin of black holes measured, and what can it tell us about our universe? Credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center Astronomers have measured the spin of a black hole buried in the heart of a galaxy located 56…

How is the spin of black holes measured, and what can it tell us about our universe? Credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center

Astronomers have measured the spin of a black hole buried in the heart of a galaxy located 56 million light years away, and discovered it was spinning quickly – about as quickly as it could go. That was the big news, based on a paper in Nature, in recent days.

So how did the astronomers make their measurement? And what does it mean?

For a long time, black holes were nothing but a theoretical curiosity, but from the 1970s it became clear there were spots in the universe where observational properties could only be due to the presence of an immense gravitational field.
Within our own galaxy, there are lots of black holes with a mass similar to the sun, but over the last 15 years it has become apparent that hearts of galaxies host supermassive black holes with masses many millions and billions time that of the sun.


Supermassive black holes are far too small to be imaged by any telescope we have; and to compound matters, to state the obvious, they are black. But, though physically small, their immense mass ensures their gravitational pull reaches out into the galaxy.

By measuring the speeds of stars orbiting near these central black holes, we can determine the gravitational forces acting on them and measure the mass. This has been spectacularly successful in our own Milky Way, where astronomers have pinned the mass of the central black hole to be more than four million times the mass of the sun.
At such large distances, the gravity the orbiting stars experience carries no information about how quickly the black hole is rotating, and so – to measure this – we need to get a lot closer to the hole, into the regime where gravity no longer resembles the simple laws of Newton. At this point we have to worry about the relativistic effects of Einstein.
In 1963, the New Zealand mathematician Roy Kerr cracked the equations for spinning black holes.
At large distances, spinning and non-spinning black holes have the same influence on orbits, tugging on stars in the same way. But as we get closer, the effects of relativity grow, and we find the spinning black hole gives space-time a twist not seen around stationary black holes. And the more a black hole spins, the more space-time is twisted.
Such space-time twists influence the motion of stuff moving close to the black hole, and by tracking nearby orbits we can work out the spin of the black hole. And in this respect we’re lucky: falling material rarely drops straight in, but tends to miss and ends up orbiting before making its final plunge.
Accretion disks
Because of the above, some supermassive black holes are surrounded by immense, brightly-glowing accretion disks, with material whizzing around, heating through friction, at speeds approaching that of light.

EnlargeThe arms are in this galaxy are stars. The radiation from the accretion disk is the bright spot at the centre. Credit: John Bahcall/Mike Disney/NASA/ESABut, even with our best telescopes, all we see is an intense point of light at the heart of a galaxy. So how can we ever see how the accretion disk is moving, and hence work out the spin?
The high temperature of the disk ensures elements such as iron atoms glow brightly, producing sharply-defined emissions of X-ray radiation.
The rapid rotation of the disk means some points are moving towards us, and some away, and the well-known Doppler effect works to change the observed energies of the X-rays, broadening the emission line we observe. So we can measure the speed of the disk rotation.
But as any good car-salesman will tell you, there’s more. We have to remember that as this hot material spirals in towards the black hole, the effects of relativity grow larger.
With that in mind, two key features have to be considered.
Mind the gap
The first is the concept of an “innermost stable orbit”. In Newtonian gravity, you can safely orbit, without having to use rockets to support yourself, at any height above a massive object.
While this holds for larger orbits around black holes, for material that strays too close, there are no stable orbits and material simply falls in.
If we imagine Earth had an innermost stable orbit at 1000km above the surface, satellites we launched to 1,001km would happily orbit, but those at 999km would simply fall back to Earth.
The existence of an innermost stable orbit means there is a gap in the middle of the accretion disk, a demarcation where matter can happily orbit beyond this distance but rapidly spirals in when the radius is crossed.
Remarkably, the size of the gap depends strongly on the spin of the black hole, with the more twisted space-time of a highly-rotating hole allowing material to orbit closer than that of a stationary black hole.
But material getting closer orbits faster. So if we can see how quickly material is moving (which we determine from the widths of the iron lines) we can start to measure the size of the gap.
The second effect dictates how photons from the accretion disk travel to to telescope. While classical physics tells us that rays travel in straight lines, the warped gravity of Einstein’s relativity means that photons can follow complex paths after being emitted, twisting and turning as they climb away from the disk.
Combining these effects means that the nice sharp peaks of iron emission are broadened and distorted, and the shape of the distortion tells us how much the central black hole is spinning.
And this is precisely what is measured.
Why should we care?
We know the supermassive black holes in the heart of galaxies must have been born in the earliest epochs of the universe, probably in the deaths of the first generation of massive stars.
These “seed” black holes must have had masses not much larger than a few hundred or thousand times that of our sun, and so to reach the masses of millions and billions of solar masses, they must have grown rapidly, feeding on in-falling material.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Travel inside a black hole.

It is therefore thought such black holes must have grown with their host galaxies forming around them, and the flow of matter into one is implicitly tied with the flow of matter into the other. And as matter doesn’t simply fall directly in, the spins of the host galaxy and central black hole should be similarly related.
So understanding the spins of central black holes gives us clues to how large galaxies, such as our own Milky Way, came into being.
How’s that for a positive spin!


The Conversation

This story is published courtesy of The Conversation (under Creative Commons-Attribution/No derivatives).

view popular
send feedback to editors

5 /5 (1 vote)


Move the slider to adjust rank threshold, so that you can hide some of the comments.

Display comments:
newest first



5 /5 (1 vote)

more news

Related Stories

Jan 16, 2012
Black hole jets

May 23, 2011
Black holes spinning faster than ever before

Feb 27, 2013
Supermassive black hole spins super-fast

May 27, 2011
Measuring galaxy black hole masses

Relevant PhysicsForums posts

Do planets “wave” in their orbits?
15 hours ago

I was wondering if a planet moves up and down as they orbit the Sun due to the differing inclinations of the other planets? In other words do the planets move in a wave like motion in their…

Expansion of the universe
23 hours ago
As I understand it, the rate at which the universe is expanding is increasing. Can the rate of expansion ever exceed the speed of light? If/when it does exceed the speed of light, Does that mean that…

Naked Eye Visibility of Mars.
Mar 03, 2013
I have been trying to figure out why I can see Mars, by eye, even when it is very close to a bright, almost full Moon. Firstly, Mars at its closest to Earth only has an angular diameter of less than…

Need a good analogy of finding life in the universe
Mar 03, 2013
My friends who don’t believe life elsewhere exists often use the argument of “Well if life exists then why haven’t they found us yet?”

The only thing I can think of to explain it to them is it…

earliest rocky planets
Mar 01, 2013
I’m looking for a more or less definitive answer for the earliest time when rocky planets could form. I saw one thread in this forum that addressed this, but there was no resolution. My guess is…

Astronomy paper help – professor doesn’t understand my wording
Feb 28, 2013

First off, I’m not sure where to post this topic. I was thinking either the homework section, or General Astronomy, but I chose to put it here because my question relates to a research paper…

More from Physics Forums – General Astronomy

More news stories

Curiosity sleeps as solar blast races toward Mars

NASA says the Curiosity rover is hunkering down after the sun unleashed a blast headed for Mars.

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

1 hour ago |
not rated yet |

Comet Pan-STARRS holds promise for stargazers

A rare bright comet shows up in the northern hemisphere this week, cruising past Earth with promise of spectacular naked-eye viewings of the giant ball of ice and dust streaking the twilight sky with a blazing …

Space & Earth / Space Exploration

4 hours ago |
5 / 5 (3) |

Astronomers refine measurement of distance to nearest galaxy

A team of astronomers including Carnegie’s Ian Thompson have managed to improve the measurement of the distance to our nearest neighbor galaxy and, in the process, refine an astronomical calculation that …

Space & Earth / Astronomy

3 hours ago |
3.8 / 5 (4) |

47 Tucanae: Probing extreme matter through observations of neutron stars

( —Neutron stars, the ultra-dense cores left behind after massive stars collapse, contain the densest matter known in the Universe outside of a black hole. New results from Chandra and other X-ray …

Space & Earth / Astronomy

3 hours ago |
5 / 5 (2) |

The science of sinkholes

A devastating sinkhole occurred in Florida on February 28, 2013, raising questions and concerns about this incredible phenomenon. Around 20% of the U.S. lies in areas susceptible to sinkhole events, highlighting …

Space & Earth / Earth Sciences

5 hours ago |
2.7 / 5 (3) |

Scientists discover distant relatives of gardeners’ friend

( —In a new article published in the Journal of Paleontology, two paleontologists, including one from Simon Fraser University, describe the most diverse group of fossilized green lacewing insects …

Other Sciences / Archaeology & Fossils
59 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Steer clear of ‘miracle cures,’ other bogus health products: FDA

(HealthDay)—Fraudulent health products are commonplace and can cause serious injury or even death, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration warns.

Medicine & Health / Medications
53 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Cost of diabetes care in US keeps climbing

(HealthDay)—The total cost of diabetes in the United States jumped from $174 billion in 2007 to $245 billion in 2012, a new report shows.

Medicine & Health / Diabetes
43 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Folate and vitamin B12 reduce disabling schizophrenia symptoms in some patients

Adding the dietary supplements folate and vitamin B12 to treatment with antipsychotic medication improved a core symptom component of schizophrenia in a study of more than 100 patients. The study focused on negative symptoms …

Medicine & Health / Psychology & Psychiatry
32 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

People with MS-related memory and attention problems have signs of extensive brain damage

People with multiple sclerosis (MS) who have cognitive problems, or problems with memory, attention, and concentration, have more damage to areas of the brain involved in cognitive processes than people with MS who do not …

Medicine & Health / Neuroscience
32 minutes ago |
not rated yet |

Review: Despite flaws, voice search has potential

I never thought I’d be telling my phone what to do. But I often find myself talking to various digital assistants—Siri on the iPhone and Google Now on Android devices—to request driving directions, restaurant recommendations …

Technology / Internet
1 hour ago |
1 / 5 (1) |